strategic foresight in central banks – Financial institution Underground

Julia Giese and Jacqueline Koay

We dwell in an period of fast change, complexity and uncertainty. Over current years, extreme world shocks have been frequent, with profound implications for our financial system and monetary system. But such shocks are unattainable to forecast with any precision as they aren’t extrapolations of previous relationships. Our financial system and monetary system are topic to longer-running tendencies resembling technological advances, demographics, geopolitical shifts and local weather change which might be blown off target or altered in surprising methods. The place forecasts are certain to fail, strategic foresight instruments might help as they’re a way for practitioners to grasp the dynamics of change (and the way this might impression the financial system and monetary stability) by imagining completely different futures and telling tales round how tendencies may work together to offer rise to unexpected shocks.

It’s a VUCA world: of black swans and Knightian uncertainty

The long run is unknown, unformed, unpredictable, unsure, and but to be decided. Within the Nineteen Eighties, the time period VUCA (volatility, uncertainty, complexity, ambiguity) entered our vocabulary to explain an ever-changing world. An analogous time period is TUNA (turbulent, unsure, novel, ambiguous). In a VUCA or TUNA world, making ready for central case outcomes could also be vast of the mark. There are the issues we all know we don’t know (identified unknowns) and there are issues that we don’t know we don’t know (unknown unknowns). That is also called Rumsfeld Matrix, after Donald Rumsfeld who used the time period in a press briefing in regards to the Iraq Battle.

Wild playing cards are low-probability, high-impact occasions. These are the identified unknowns – arduous to foretell with any certainty however considerably anticipated. Unknown unknowns are utterly surprising shocks, also called black swans or Knightian uncertainty (after the economist Frank Knight), which Keynes known as issues about which ‘there is no such thing as a scientific foundation on which to kind any calculable likelihood no matter’.  Each kinds of occasions usually are not forecastable with any precision utilizing quantitative measures.  

From uncertainty across the future to a set of futures

The place forecasts usually are not strong to substantial shocks or structural adjustments, instruments to think about completely different futures might help. The Authorities Workplace for Science makes use of the phrases ‘A number of Futures’ and ‘The Cones of Uncertainty’ of their futures pondering and foresight instruments to make sense of doable future change, discover the dynamics and uncertainties of that change, describe what the longer term is likely to be like and perceive potential implications (Determine 1).

Determine 1: The cone of uncertainty

Supply: Authorities Workplace for Science.

Moderately than placing all our eggs into one proverbial basket and ignoring the likelihood that different baskets exist, strategic foresight advocates being ready for different believable eventualities – for various futures. Situation planning permits us to deliver these completely different futures to life.

Situation planning has been utilized by many governmental our bodies in addition to massive corporations as a instrument for framing strategic conversations for the aim of facilitating organisational preparedness. For instance, Shell has developed situations for round 50 years, permitting the organisation to reply, amongst others, to the oil value shocks of the Seventies. And governmental departments throughout a large set of nations have additionally been on the forefront of strategic foresight. Coverage Horizons Canada, Singapore’s Centre for Strategic Futures and the EU’s European Technique and Coverage Evaluation System usually publish reviews on future tendencies and situations. Within the UK, the Authorities Workplace for Science has produced a Futures Toolkit to allow wider adoption of the method in addition to a Development Deck. Furthermore, some worldwide organisations have a strategic foresight unit. For instance, the OECD’s unit publishes situations reviews and usually convenes seminars and conferences for public sector strategic foresight practitioners from throughout the globe.

Nevertheless, central banks have but to embrace this method absolutely as a complimentary instrument to extra conventional forecasting or threat evaluation instruments. In organisations the place choices are made based mostly on information (even when the information is imperfect and incomplete), a cultural shift could also be wanted to start exploring prospects that don’t solely depend on possibilities based mostly on historic distributions. Some change is afoot as policymakers at central banks have had to answer the 2008 world monetary disaster and newer world shocks.

Situation evaluation has been utilized by central banks and regulators within the context of stress testing monetary establishments. For instance, the Financial institution of England’s System-wide Exploratory Situation was particularly designed with an inventory of sensitivities to uncover additional points when a shock is launched to the system, and the Local weather Biannual Exploratory Situation explored long-term dangers to monetary establishments from local weather change. Furthermore, Dr Ben Bernanke appeared into current forecast efficiency of the Financial institution of England’s Financial Coverage Committee and substantial reforms are underway to replace processes round evaluation for financial evaluation, together with paving the way in which for introducing situations along with the central forecast.

Nevertheless, the kind of state of affairs evaluation described on this article considers an extended time horizon in addition to a broader vary of interacting adjustments, together with societal and environmental developments that might current each upside and draw back dangers. Furthermore, the Financial institution’s Unbiased Analysis Workplace report of horizon scanning notes the worth of a extra systematic and joined up method to horizon scanning. We consider that there could be nice profit in adopting strategic foresight instruments in central banking to discover longer-term tendencies and structural adjustments, shifting focus to tales round believable futures, typically at a time horizon far past what we’d sometimes search to forecast (Determine 2). This might additionally assist strategic imaginative and prescient, internally and externally: some central banks have anchored their general technique round futures pondering (the Central Financial institution of Eire stresses the ‘future-focused’ factor of their technique).

Determine 2: The TUNA surroundings and why conventional methods don’t actually work

Supply: © Jacqueline Koay (2024).

The artwork of state of affairs planning

Situation planning might help facilitate deep, forward-looking discussions that may crystallise priorities and be certain that insurance policies are strong to various futures with broad functions in data-driven organisations like central banks – be this for evaluation supporting policymakers or for company technique.

The method additionally permits for identification of unconscious baseline assumptions – the so-called ‘ghost state of affairs‘. We’d suppose that we take a long-term view, however by specializing in one model of the longer term, sometimes extrapolated from the previous, we miss out on various challenges arising. By exploring completely different situations, with orthogonal developments, state of affairs planning can overcome this bias, by ‘reframing’ one’s thoughts. Take the London 2012 Olympics. Residents had been informed to keep away from public transport. Having taken the tube to work for years, one of many authors of this put up began biking. After preliminary challenges, I by no means appeared again – my thoughts had been reframed by an intervention that required pondering (and performing) in another way. Eventualities planning can present exactly this intervention.

One of many methodologies to develop situations is the Oxford Situation Planning Method (OSPA). The OSPA method begins with defining a really clear objective and figuring out the precise supposed use for the planning course of. To develop situations, one may then set up a four-by-four grid alongside two axes, with every axis representing a selected driver of structural change (resembling velocity of technological adoption or growing geopolitical fragmentation). Eventualities are then developed for every quadrant utilizing the inherent traits of the axes and extra assumptions. One other method within the situations toolkit includes manufacturing situations from analysing information or data of recent and rising tendencies and on the lookout for patterns within the information to develop a narrative (‘state of affairs’) that might clarify the patterns. Programs pondering might be launched by exploring the interconnectedness of a state of affairs’s underlying tendencies, and the way these relationships might probably work together with each other to result in new, long-term structural adjustments.

This method, whichever method is employed to construct the situations, is inherently inclusive. It really works greatest if a various set of inputs is sought, and other people with completely different viewpoints come collectively. In our expertise, individuals benefit from the expertise of state of affairs constructing and discussing the ‘so what’. It unleashes inventive potential that’s typically confined to team-building workouts and frees the thoughts to suppose in another way, to ‘reframe’.  And importantly, given the wealth of printed materials on this area, it doesn’t should be too useful resource intensive. Traits or situations from different organisations can function a place to begin for a extra bespoke train, the place within the case of central banks, the financial or monetary stability penalties of particular tendencies or situations might be labored out in additional element.

The great thing about state of affairs planning, and strategic foresight extra broadly, is that the muse is plausibility, not likelihood. This enhances approaches sometimes utilized in central banks resembling information evaluation, stress testing and modelling, including qualitative strategies to the toolkit that permit specific exploration of uncertainty and unknowns.

Julia Giese works within the Financial institution’s Worldwide Surveillance Division and Jacqueline Koay works within the Financial institution’s Rising Dangers and Particular Tasks Division.

If you wish to get in contact, please e mail us at bankunderground@bankofengland.co.uk or go away a remark beneath.

Feedback will solely seem as soon as authorised by a moderator, and are solely printed the place a full title is equipped. Financial institution Underground is a weblog for Financial institution of England workers to share views that problem – or assist – prevailing coverage orthodoxies. The views expressed listed below are these of the authors, and usually are not essentially these of the Financial institution of England, or its coverage committees.